2 · What a constitution actually does
This course is open while its review is still in progress. Every course here gets a source-by-source citation review before it is marked reviewed; this one has not finished that process yet. How review works
Before you can classify constitutions, know what the thing is FOR. A constitution is not a mission statement and not a list of a country's values. It is a working document that does four specific jobs, and every axis you will learn in this course is a way of asking how it does one of them.
The four jobs
| Job | What it means | The verb |
|---|---|---|
| Constitute | It creates the state's institutions: a legislature, an executive, courts | MAKES |
| Distribute | It hands specific powers to each institution and level | DIVIDES |
| Limit | It fences the state off from the people through rights and rules | RESTRAINS |
| Entrench | It puts itself above ordinary law, so a mere statute cannot override it | PROTECTS |
The word "constitution" is the first job wearing its own name. To constitute is to bring into being. Before the document, there is no legislature and no presidency as legal entities; the constitution calls them into existence and says what each one is. Course 1's "who acted?" has an answer only because some constitution constituted that body.
Distribute and limit: the two directions of power
The middle two jobs point in opposite directions and it is worth holding them apart.
Distribute is about power BETWEEN state bodies. It says the legislature makes law, the executive carries it out, the courts judge disputes, and (in a federation) the center does these things and the regions do those. This is the machinery Sections 2 and 3 take apart.
Limit is about power BETWEEN the state and the person. A bill of rights, due-process guarantees, and hard limits on what any branch may do are the state fencing itself in. A constitution that only distributes power and never limits it can organize a very efficient tyranny. The two jobs are separate achievements, and a country can be strong on one and weak on the other.
Entrench: the job that makes it a constitution and not a statute
The fourth job is the quiet one that makes the other three stick. A constitution claims to be higher law: ordinary legislation that conflicts with it is invalid, and the constitution can be changed only by some harder process than passing a normal law. Take entrenchment away and you do not have a constitution; you have a statute with a grand title, because the next ordinary majority could rewrite it on a Tuesday. How strongly a constitution is entrenched (how much harder it is to amend than an ordinary law) is a whole axis of its own, and Section 3 measures it.
Why the jobs come before the types
Every classification in this course is really a question about one of these jobs:
- Presidential versus parliamentary is a question about how the constitution DISTRIBUTES executive power and ties it to the legislature.
- Federal versus unitary is a question about how it DISTRIBUTES power across territory.
- Codified versus uncodified, rigid versus flexible are questions about how, and how hard, it ENTRENCHES.
Learn the jobs, and the types stop being vocabulary and start being answers. This is analysis of structure, not legal advice.
Sources
- U.S. Const. art. VI. https://constitution.congress.gov/constitution/article-6/
- Elkins, Z., Ginsburg, T., & Melton, J. (2009). The endurance of national constitutions. Cambridge University Press.
Also saves the next lesson, so you can keep going offline.